Godless Living

Living a fulfilled life without God

In Response to the Bombing of the US Consulate in Libya

I’m sad about the attack on the US Consulate that happened last night.  It’s sad to see the loss of lives over protests that apparently began as a result of a film that had been released that mocked the prophet Mohammed.  I don’t know why people think that criticism of their religion is a valid reason to take someone’s life… even more the lives of people who had nothing to do with it.  I don’t get it.

Not only am I sad about the attack, I’m also sad about the dialogue that I imagine will take place now.  The secular community will be waving the “I told you so” flag around and touting the damaging aspects of religious faith.  The religious community will be emphasizing that this is not the way their particular faith is and that these are just extremists.  They will also wave their “I told you so” flag around by saying that people need to be more respectful and quit criticizing religion.

While I tend to agree with the secular community, I do think it’s important to recognize the enemy and to have realistic expectations about the near future of humanity.  I think the secular community needs to be cautious expecting that religious faith will just be eradicated soon.  There are way too many very decent and good people who belong to religious faith with whom we share this planet.  I wish there were better ways for us to stand together.  I think we have a few common enemies… especially if we’re talking about standing with the more liberal forms of faith.

I know this is a heated topic and one to which I realize not everyone will agree with me.  However, I’m just not able to write off my dear friends and family who are religious.  Regardless of what those of us in the secular community think about faith, their faith really does bring them comfort and often makes them better people.  I think they could do this without religious faith, but what I’m saying is that I don’t personally know anyone whose faith leads them to do destructive things like bomb buildings, etc.  I think good people will be good people and bad people will be bad people.  I realize that religion gives a justification to people who want to do bad things, but the reality is that those people would likely do those bad things anyway.  People that want to kill others and harm others will find their justification for doing so.

So I guess my message is that I’m frustrated with these extremists who used their faith as an excuse to kill people.  There are not strong enough words to convey how much I hate this.  However, in an effort to not create more tension and animosity, my message to those people I know that are religious would be that I know they are not my enemy.  We don’t agree on many things, but I consider most of them very decent and sincere people with whom I’m happy to share this planet.  We need more people interested in sharing the planet.  I’m very troubled lately over the increasing divisiveness in more than just the religious arena.  I don’t completely know the answers since I think some of the debate is necessary, but I think we can do better in living peacefully with others (myself included).  We owe it not only to the victims who died in this most recent attack, but to the millions of people who have died because of our inability to learn to live peacefully with others.  How do we have the necessary conversations without the divisiveness?  How do we learn to partner with people who may think differently than us on many things, but similar to us on the important things?  How do we learn to better share our planet?

Advertisements

3 comments on “In Response to the Bombing of the US Consulate in Libya

  1. jrconcepcion
    September 13, 2012

    I share you concerns regarding human development and outrage over the attacks. As a secular humanist, I agree intimately with not only your views of the invalidity of religion and religious beliefs but also the respect and love given and received by religious family and friends. And I think you hit the right spot when you mention “the debate is necessary.”

    The debate is partly why free speech is important; it allows society a level of introspection unavailable anywhere else, and us non-believers know introspection is key to understand why we believe what we believe. Although freedom of speech itself does not prevent divisiveness (it seems to contribute to it much of the time), I believe being accustomed to unsavory ideas is the psychological foundation of tolerance. The Muslim World is coming into the Modern World centuries after the West, where secular motivations, not religious motivations, becomes dominant in most of society’s institutions (government, business, schools, law, etc). Many people in the Muslim world, and some very loud ones in developed countries, have a hard time reconciling their faith with modernity, in large part due to being utterly shocked when a non-believer (or other-believer) speaks his or her mind. How do we have necessary conversations you ask? I believe one factor is exposure to new ideas and time and how they can massage narrow-mindedness is many, albeit not all, people. You can’t expect open-mindedness from people who lived and lived around others that had a very narrow lifestyle.

    It seems to be “learning” is’int so much the issue as “putting in the effort” in partnering with people who may think differently than us on many things, but similar to us on the important things. I’m sure there are things to learn but I also think much learning comes after establishing a relationship. Same (almost) goes to you last question, where it’s less about learning and more about the incentive to share our planet. Why? It seems to me that is the better battleground.

    • godlessliving
      September 13, 2012

      Great comments. Thanks for reading, but also for contributing to the conversation. You make some good points that will add to my continued struggle to find balance in being too aggressive and not aggressive enough.

  2. Snowbrush
    November 8, 2012

    I respect your efforts to not isolate yourself from anyone who has the audacity to disagree with you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Information

This entry was posted on September 12, 2012 by in Uncategorized.
%d bloggers like this: